Better night than expected - 08/20/2020

Thursday 8/20/2020 promised to be clear night with average seeing according to Clearsky Charts and NOAA. I decided to head for the Harvard library darksite with the goal of imaging the Crescent, the Eastern and Western Veil nebulae using the Starizona Night Owl gambling on 120s sub frames at f/4. That proved a mistake. The results were under exposed and noisy. I won't bother posting the images here. In the future I will try imaging with 300s sub frames that yielded better results at a higher f/6.4 focal ratio in the past. 

Fortunately, I also imaged Comet Neowise, M8, M16, M17, M20 and M13 on the same night. Sub frames were acquired with 30s exposures at a gain of 120.  The images appear below. The images are pretty okay but could be  better. The auto-guider was quite erratic along the RA axis resulting in elongated stars. With the waxing moon I will focus on debugging this issue locally starting with running the PHD2 setup wizard. 

On a different note flat frames captured during twilight were at the wrong focus making them useless. I decided to keep the optical assembly together and collect a set of flat frames at home next day. The first set, taken from a lamp illuminated wall looked good but yielded ugly images marred with gradients. At first I assumed the problem was camera settings and light pollution. On a whim I tried using a white jpeg image on my LED HDTV screen as a flat frame target. It worked resulting in the  images below. 😊

Comet C/2020 F3 Neowise

M8 (Lagoon Nebula)

M16 (Eagle Nebula)

M17 (Omega Nebula)

M13 (Hercules Cluster)

M20 (Trifid Nebula)

So Begins Globular Cluster Season.

Globular clusters (GC) are some of my favorite targets for this time of the year with short spring and summer nights and the annoyance of daylight saving time. With sunsets around 2030 and astronomical twilight's around 2240 globulars can usually be acquired in less than 15 minutes making for productive nights of imaging. 

Why do I keep coming back to these low hanging fruits? I like to think I can improve on my past performance and take advantage very rare good seeing Northeast nights. Most of these targets are low in the southern sky making it challenging to image them with the denser more turbulent air and refraction.

A few recent examples appear below. All of these globulars were acquired from a favorite Harvard, MA darkish site with 15 x 30s subframes with a ASI294MC-Pro, Starizona Night Owl 0.4x focal reducer and Celestron 8 on an Advanced VX mount. 

While I call this Globular Cluster Season there are many more  open clusters favorably placed this time of the year. Look for images of those in up coming posts. 

Messier 3

Messier 5

Messier 53

Messier 13

Messier 92

NGC5897

Messier 4

Messier 10

Messier 12

Messier 14

Ad hoc bonus night

If the NOAA forecast for a dark site is partly cloudy I don't bother planning a DSO imaging mission. However, on the afternoon of this mission I noticed the skies were sunny and cloudless. Upon checking Clear Sky Chart for Harvard MA it was forecasting an above average viewing night. Other than picking a few Galaxy Season targets little planning was needed. The night went well with the images appearing below. Galaxy images were averaged from 15x60s exposure sub frames. Globular clusters were averaged from 25x30s exposure sub frames.

Messier 51 (Whirlpool Galaxy)

 

Messier 64(Black Eye Galaxy)

Messier 3

Messier 53

Messier 85(center) and NGC 4394(lower center)

M86 (low right), M84(upper center),
NGC4402(lower left), NGC4388(right center)

NGC4565

Galaxy Season

The coronavirus pandemic put my astro-imaging on hold. Two favorite Harvard MA public area dark sites are temporarily closed due to the pandemic. Luckily I was recently able to image from the unlighted parking lot of a friendly fruit stand with a great view of the skies. Thanks to surrounding towns Harvard's skies are starting to rival the light polluted skies of Boston suburbs. That said they are still worth traveling to.

With two rare clear sky nights in a row I was able to do quite a bit of galaxy imaging using the Starizona Night Owl focal reducer alluded to in earlier posts. I decided to experiment with 15 x 1min sub-frames instead of the more typical 6 x 5min I've used in the past. The results are a pleasant surprise. UPDATE: Actually, according to Robin Glover's CMOS color camera astrophotography YouTube video it's not such a surprise after all. 

Interesting note: Images from the first and better night sky-wise were plagued with an unpleasant gradient brightening on the left side. I hypothesized was due to flat frames with histograms with too many points below 20%. Flat frame histograms should fall between 20% and 80%.  I adjusted this on the second night and in a Hail Mary play applied one of these flats to the previous night's images. Any serious imager knows this is a no-no because flats must be taken with the exact optical configuration used to acquire the images. Despite this, the result was a successful, albeit imperfect salvaging operation made possible because I typically insert the camera with the same orientation around to the telescope's optical axis. 

Note: Galaxy Season refers to the many Coma cluster galaxies in the  in the southern spring evening sky. Also, Galaxy season doesn't preclude imaging comets, globular clusters or gaseous nebulae as exemplified by the first four images.

 

Comet C/2017T2 PANSTARRS

.Messier 3 Globular Cluster 

Messier 13 

Messier 97 Owl Nebula

Messier 51 Whirlpool Galaxy

Messier 63 Sunflower Galaxy

Messier 85

Messier 94

Messier 101

Messier 106

Messier 109

NGC4613 Whale Galaxy

M81, M82, M51, NGC2841

It's Spring and with Coma Berenices with its accompanying cluster of galaxies it's the beginning of galaxy season. I thought I would get a head start  practicing on with three of my favorite galaxies M81, M82 and M51. NGC2841 is thrown in as a bonus. These won't be my only  visits to these non-Coma Berenices targets as they grace my northern hemisphere zenith during the next month or so. The Coma cluster requires I get out of heavily light polluted Frederick Maryland  to one of my darkish sites and when the galaxies are highest in the southern sky. 

Sadly, as I write this, the world is in the midst of a crippling, deadly pandemic due to the covid-19 corona virus. The effects on public health and the world economy are still to be played out. I'm fortunate, a lifelong saver/investor to be in a decent financial position despite taking a hit in the stock market. I can also be grateful for a mind engaging hobby, this one, to distract me from the current goings on. Folks, follow the experts, hand washing, social distancing, staying at home if you can. We're in for pain but will get through this. 

M81 -- 15x120s @bin1

M82 -- 15x180s @bin1

M51 -- 12x180s @bin1

NGC2481 -- 10x180s @bin1

Comet C2017T2, IC405, IC410, M33, NGC281, M42, NGC7635

Here are a few recent images acquired this 2019 winter. All were acquired at F/4 using the recently with Celestron 8+Starizona Night Owl FR+Orion SkyGlow Astrophotography filter. Camera: ZWO ASI294MC Pro, Mount: Celestron Advanced VX, Guider: Orion Magnificent Mini Autoguider. 

Look closely at Comet C2017T2 and you might notice the glow slanting down to its left. That's residual glow not zeroed out by the flat frame. Vignetting from the Night Owl is very aggressive and tough to zero out.  

Using SharpCap 3.2 I have found collecting flat frames at a narrow range of different exposures that give a histogram just above and below the "above 20%" criterion should provide a flat frame that does a good job zeroing out vignetting and artifacts. *

* More recently I have found a 20% to 80% histogram range, as recommended by SharpCap documentation works best. 

Update:03/13/2025 M33 reprocessed 

Comet C2017T2 PANSTARRS -- 15x60s @bin2

IC410 -- 6x300s @bin1

M33 (180s exposures)

IC405 -- 6x300s @ bin1

NGC281 -- 10x180s @bin1

M42 -- 25x8s @bin1

NGC7635 -- 6x300s @ Bin1

Orion Skyglow Astrophotography Filter - First Night Out

First off a night with a 66% waxing moon is far from an ideal test night. The purpose of Orion SkyGlow Astrophotography Filter is to remove various bands of artificial outdoor lighting. The moon is broad band reflected sunlight which is not fully filterable. Also making this night non-ideal was high clouds that moved in far sooner than the forecast 2300 EST cutting short the night. 

 That said I was able to image NGC7635, the bubble nebula using 15x2 min and 6x5 min  sub-frames. The Starizona Night Owl 0.4X focal reducer was used for imaging. Images were processed using Paintshop ProX9. To give a direct comparison between the two images the six steps used to process the 6x2min image were saved to a script which was then applied to the 15x2 min case. The process and cropped images appear below. 

On another note I am finding images acquired with the Starizona Night Owl are far more susceptible to the exposure conditions of the flat frames used in stacking. I image using SharpCap 3.2 and acquire flat frames over a range of exposures while keeping the logarithm of the histogram as close to a 20% to 80% range. In any case I would consider either image below to be acceptable considering the phase of the moon.

NGC7635 -- 15x2 min

NGC7635 -- 6x5 min